Getting Out of My Head

In the ending of chapter 7, Appiah discusses how certain things take on different meanings and can be interpreted differently in various cultures. He gives the example of how Levis can be considered dressy attire to some, while others think of wearing Levis as a more casual look. He explains this as, “people in each place make their own uses even of the most famous global commodities” (113). This idea I found relatable to the first quote cited from Suk Cha’s reading about how all societies are meshed together and it’s harder and harder to differentiate. All members in societies can be wearing Levis and this small relation will bring the societies to a commonality. And sooner or later if Levis market their products to more societies then it’s going to be harder to find uniqueness from first glance at various societies, in other words you’re going to have to do more than glance at a society, you’ll have to dig deeper and get to know the ways within the society to find the differences.

Later in chapter 9, Appiah brings up tolerance saying, “toleration requires a concept of the intolerable” (144). This idea I found interesting because it allowed me to realize that you can only be accepting of others if you come to terms with what you’re not in agreement with. I sort of had this realization in my service learning throughout my experience. At the start, I was so headstrong in believing that the young moms were there because they were in no position to be having kids and they needed all the help they could get and I didn’t think that’d I’d be able to identify with any of them, but as I got acquainted with YMM, I soon realized that I was putting these thoughts about the young women’s lifestyles not being acceptable in my head without taking time to consider why I felt this way. I didn’t have any specific reason for being against young motherhood, but I just felt that it was not acceptable. It’s similar to Appiah’s idea of counter-cosmopolitans, I was being a counter-cosmopolitan in thinking that every other girl in society should live according to what I thought was a suitable lifestyle. However, now my views have changed to that of a cosmopolitan because I’m seeing that the young moms have every right to make their own decisions, and if that means starting a family at 23 then so be it, it’s their life, not mine and I must make judgements based on what I deem rightful.

Standard

Looking Beyond Oneself

People in different cultures are no longer homogenous. Due to globalization and mundialization (described by Appiah and In-Suk Cha) cultures across the world have been exposed to each other. Even in 3rd world countries, people have been exposed to other cultures. This means that it might be possible to develop transcultural ethics.

In “Toward a Transcultural Ethics in a Multicultural World,” In-Suk Cha writes: “one of the reasons why modern humanity cannot claim vestiges of primordial fear of difference as viable cause for violence and conflict is that we humans share too much in common with each other in our societies. It is difficult to find any group or society that has not entered into some sort of cultural exchange with another” (5). This point made by In-Suk Cha ties in with Appiah’s idea and support of contamination. Appiah states: “When people speak for an ideal of cultural purity, sustaining the authentic culture…I find myself drawn to contamination as the name for a counter-ideal” (112).  Contamination is present in all cultures because, as In-Suk Cha wrote, every culture has exchanged something with at least one other culture. Cultural purity is also something that humans don’t need. “We do not need, have never needed…a homogeneous system of values, in order to have a home (113). In last weeks readings, Appiah said that conflict between cultures is inevitable because all cultures have differences, but these conflicts are what help the cultures interact and understand that there are more than one truths for a certain ideal. Both In-Suk Cha and Appiah are saying that cultures have all exchanged with at least one other culture, and through this interaction each individual culture has developed ways and things to live by. This also ties in to the second point from the In-Suk Cha reading says “Our obligations include examining the nature of societies in terms of their differences and similarities and in terms of how they change upon interaction” (6).

One of the main differences between a counter-cosmopolitan and a cosmopolitan is that  counter-cosmopolitans believe that there is only one truth that humans should live by. People who try to evoke universal ethics who are counter-cosmopolitans are the exact opposite of cosmopolitans who try to evoke universal ethics. This is true because counter-cosmopolitans  make “universal issues in uniformity” (145). This is the exact opposite of what I talked about in the previous paragraph about how cultures can never be homogeneous because there are different truths that different cultures live by. Transcultural ethics can not be uniform because not everyone is the same. They have to be broad. If transcultural ethics were rigid and uniform, then everyone would be the same and there would be no diversity or texture in our lives.

The people in the adult ELS classes are perfect examples of how different cultures interact and then change due to the interaction. Everyone of the students has come from a different background and are immigrants into the United States. Now that they are here they have developed their own ways to live so that they feel at home. I am also the same way because the culture of my home is completely different from the culture at Dominican. When I came to school here last year it was the first time that I had been away from home for an extended period of time. Now, looking back, I can see that I changed due to the interaction with the people here. I have made this place my home and it was because, like the immigrant ELS students, I found ways to change. Living on campus has me living with people who have different cultures. This diversity is helping me understand who I am, and I wouldn’t want roommates who were the exact same as me. Life would be uninteresting and boring if that was the case.  As In Suk-cha wrote in the second point on page 6, I am trying to use my collective responsibility to look at my obligation beyond myself. I am aware now of how the ELS students have changed due to impact that American culture has had on them.  In-Suk Cha says that we are moving toward transcultural ethics, and it will be facilitated if more people recognize their moral obligations to others. Also, I wouldn’t be able to recognize the change in the ELS students if I first didn’t recognize it in myself.

Standard

Past to Present to Future

Appiah writes about how times are changing, “relationships are changing” (103), societies are changing, and how “everything has changed” (104). “These villages are connected with more places than they were a couple of centuries ago” (102), and “the world, their world, is changing, and…some like it; some don’t” (103). People’s society’s change with time and technological advancement; they also change in response to their needs in order to benefit. Appiah writes about how even though cultures are constantly changing, they still stay the same from the roots. “If they had what they really wanted, they’d still be dressed traditionally” (106). People are stuck to their habits and culture’s traditions. Everyone grows up in a certain way, becomes accustomed to that way of living and is somewhat bound to their mold. There are people who come out of their mold but many still stay with what they are accustomed to or what they grew up with—their culture.

Appiah writes that “one truth we hold to, is that every human being has obligations to every other” (144). This is the theme that has been presented throughout the whole book, as well as the theme of understanding every other in order to live peacefully and coexist. Even though we all have different cultures and we all grew up in our own ways, we have to remember to coexist and to try to understand other people because we share this planet with them and we have to be able to take care of them just as they care for us. A lot of people fail to realize that what they do affects someone from a different area in the world—whether it is a direct effect or something that takes a while through a cycle of effects. No matter the way others affect—direct or indirect—people, no matter the distance or the connection, or lack thereof, people are still affected. “Cosmopolitans think that there are many values worth living by and that you cannot live by all of them” (144). This comes into the idea of taking care of everyone else and understanding them. Just because you understand them doesn’t mean you have to agree with them, but you will get a long better if you are accepting of their views, ideals, and ways of living. “…our knowledge is imperfect, provisional, subject to revision in the face of new evidence…” (144); we live to see different points of views and to adjust the way we think in order to be well-rounded people.

There was also this idea of being able to justify our actions against a certain group. “…when you do something that harms someone else, you must be able to justify it” (151). You end up giving reasons to your actions even to those that you are doing harm to, and it seems that we tend to care for others even if we are convinced that we don’t. Because if were to not care about our bad actions towards a group, we wouldn’t bother with explaining the reasoning behind our actions to them. We coexist enough to learn we don’t like each other, but that is not the goal of cosmopolitanism. The goal is to be understanding and realize that we all live different lives and have a right to live in the way we choose.

In order to understand what is going on in other societies though, “we would need to engage in that growth process through interacting in the communities in which we live” (4). We have to know what is going on in our own community before we can go off into other societies and try to figure things out there. However there is hope: “this expanded notion of inclusiveness, new as it is on the world stage, is a measure of how far we have come both in conceptualizing the nature of human conflict and in imagining the possibilities of solutions” (4). Now that we are starting to consider other nations and people, we have come to realize that there is a way to increase peace. We still have to keep in mind that “all human beings are different from one another individually and collectively” (5) in order to understand what is going on with other lives. We also need to “look carefully at our pasts and how they have influenced our present. And as we imagine and undertake changes in the present, we much remember that these actions of the present become the future” (6). This was my favorite quote in the whole reading—because it holds a lot of truth that we can all take with us everyday that we wake up. Everything we do affects our lives, as well as the lives of others, and we have to be cautious. 

Standard

Inevitable Progress through Toleration and Kindness

In Appiah’s chapter 7, he discusses how cosmopolitanism has contaminated culture by explaining that “[people] who complain about the homogeneity produced by globalization often fail to notice that globalization is, equally, a threat to homogeneity” (101).   We this in our everyday lives, as cosmopolitanism has connected us worldwide, where Coca Cola and McDonalds are known even in the most remote parts of the world;  culture always, and inevitability, contaminates. In reality, these human differences are important because we, as people, are able to learn from our differences; however, “[if] we want to preserve a wide range of human conditions because it allows free people the best chance to make their own lives, there is no place for the enforcement of diversity by trapping people within a kind of difference they long to escape” (105).  Being different is not always better because, sometimes, we learn from our differences what our own cultures are missing and why they need to progress and change.

Next, Appiah discusses the counter-cosmopolitans, or those whom are opposed to other cultures being explored and interacted with; specifically, Appiah focuses on the Muslim extremists that are bound and determined to keep their cultures preserved.  The reason why there is this extreme reaction to integration is that these “neofundamentalists, violent or not, [often] exemplify the possibility of a kind of universal ethics that inverts the picture of cosmopolitanism . . . [because universalism] without toleration, it’s clear, turns easily to murder” (140).  I firmly believe, as Appiah states, that these extreme reactions come as a result of a lack of cultural understanding and toleration.  Perhaps we may not agree with certain cultural practices and perhaps they are some that harm humanity that must be changed, but the root of being able to make assessments of another culture lies with first tolerating the culture that is trying to be understood.  With this toleration, people feel objectified and misunderstood, which leads to angry and anti-cosmopolitian reactions.

Finally, Appiah discusses the “stranger kindness” dilemma about how and when should strangers commit acts of kindness to help those in need.  According to the Singer principle, you are required to “prevent bad things from happening if the cost is something less awful” (160). This is aptly illustrated through a local tragedy that just happened in my hometown:  a boy’s dog got swept out to sea, the boy went after the dog, the boy’s father went after the boy, the boy and the dog returned to shore, then the mother and the boy went back out to sea to get the father, but all three of them drowned.  Within this framework, Singer’s principle comes into high moral contention:  was the cost of saving the dog worth the cost of the boy’s life?  Was the cost of saving the boy worth the father’s life?  Was the cost of the father’s life worth the boy’s and the mom’s life?  I don’t know the answer because I wasn’t there to make the choice; furthermore, the logical answers for what each actor in the situation should have done become irrelevant because there were emotional and moral dilemmas that each actor faced.  Thus, this illustrates that “life is full of hard decisions [and] that it’s not easy to identify single principles, like the Singer principle that tell you what to do” (162).  There is no single solution or answer to moral dilemmas that require action, but we, as humans, do have an internal drive to minimize and control the pain of others that we can.

Trying these ideas back into my service learning, I was to question whether encouraging the Rwandan girls to pursue higher education was an attempt to Americanize their world when Appiah appropriately pointed out that culture is inherently contaminated and there is nothing wrong with that; part of cosmopolitanism is that we learn from our differences and, through those differences, we learn from others how to best improve own our lives and understanding of the world.  The Rwandan girls realize just this because their culture has been tolerated in the process; they see education as a social improvement beyond what they could expect normally in their own culture, so they strive to become further educated.  Finally, the reason why OAD exists is because Barb recognized the lack of educational opportunity for Rwandan women and, because of the lack of education and gender equality, she saw the global cost of not taking action.  For Barb, and the rest of OAD, they lived the Singer principle by seeing that the cost of doing nothing was worse than the cost of helping these girls get into American colleges.

Standard

Kaleidoscope

“…it is not an invisible hand that moves us, it is individual and collective agency” (5).

We can all agree that in more ways than not we are all different.  We go about living life with different values, morals, outlooks, and opinions; although they may be internalized.  Yet we live within our communities and societies often trying to conform to a level of normalcy that has been laid out by those “above” and before us.  It is almost a false sense of security, as we hunker down in our blanket of norm and tradition.  Life is continually changing and as Darwin once said, it is the survival of the fittest.  This is not determined necessarily by strength, but by the ability and willingness to adapt to the ever changing environment around you.  It must be understood that although our differences create a uniqueness between us, it can can still easily divide us. “We need to remember it however if we are to understand why, how and what sort of differences come to divide us in destructive ways” (4).  In Cosmopolitanism, John Stuart Mill was quoted,

If it were only that people have diversities of taste, that is reason enough for not attempting to shape them all after one model.  But different persons also require different conditions for their spiritual development; and can no more exist healthily in the same moral, than all the variety of plants can exist in the same physical, atmosphere and climate.  The same things which are helps to one person towards the cultivation of his higher nature, are hindrances to another…  (104)

In correlation with this quote, Appiah provides his own interpretation on the matter, “If we want to preserve a wide range of human conditions because it allows free people the best chance to make their won lives, there is not place for the enforcement of diversity by trapping people within a kind of difference they long to escape” (105).

Bringing in Toward a Transcultural Ethics in a Multicultural World alongside Cosmopolitanism we will begin to examine the ideas of globalization, mundialization and the like.  Globalization has been defined as, “…the process or vehicle by which ideas, habits, worldviews travel from one culture to another and are transformed in the process” (6).  Mundialization,”…refers to historical human society and the earth inhabited by humankind” (6).  The two connect together on different focal points and thus we are able to see that,

mundialization…the taking in of the outside world into our own lifeworlds, occurs through globalization, a process by which the ideas and customs of other cultures are transported into our homeworlds. In this process, what was once strange and unfamiliar is transformed into something comfortable and familiar. This is the process that is generally known as cultural assimilation and, by virtue of which the boundaries of our individual homeworlds become constantly widened. This phenomenon is called the ‘mundialization of home.’ What effects the mundialization of home is the mediation of common elements found in both the schemata of orientation of the homeworld and in that of the strange or alien world. (6)

Due to to the continual process of mundialization, our schemata utilized in our interpretations of the world constantly evolve and transform as time goes on.  Thus, allowing us a more in depth, wise and wide comprehension of our reality.

In chapter 9 Appiah discusses the counter-cosmopolitans and the cosmopolitans.  In terms of cosmopolitans, there is the understanding that, “Toleration requires a concept of the intolerable…cosmopolitans believe in universal truth…it is the realism about how hard the truth is to find [that guides them]….One truth [held on to], is that every human being has obligations to every other.  Everybody matters: that is [the] central idea.  And it sharply limits the scope of [their] tolerance” (144).  Two main aspects of cosmopolitanism are the commitment to pluralism and fallibilism.  Counter-cosmopolitans on the other hand, do in fact believe that there exists one right way for all of humanity to live by and that all of the differences between every human being is not a display of uniqueness, but a minor details in the background.  “For the counter-cosmopolitans, then, universalism issues in uniformity…..Our understanding of toleration means interacting on terms of respect with those who see the world differently…..cosmopolitans think [they] might learn something even from those [they] disagree with.  [They] think people have a right to their own lives” (146).  Appiah describes at the end of chapter 9 how, “[t]he real challenge to cosmopolitans isn’t the belief that other people don’t matter at all; it’s the belief that they don’t matter very much” (153).

In reading chapter 10 I came across several supposed principles to live by:

If you can prevent something bad from happening at the cost of something less bad, you ought to do it.

If you are the person in the best position to prevent something really awful, and it won’t cost you much to do so, do it.

On the other hand a significant reason, “…that life is full of hard decisions is precisely that it’s not easy to identify single principles” (162).

In all finality, “Cosmopolitanism is about intelligence and curiosity as well as engagement” (168).

In correlation with my service-learning experience,  I think back to the when Appiah stated that, “…our obligation is not to carry the whole burden alone.  Each of us should do our fair share; but we cannot be required to do more” (164).  I think of all the children I work with and the similarity of all their situations and the disparity that surrounds them, and the utter lack of resources.  Kids Club, the community, and even myself can only do so much to help them and their families.  Believe me at times I wish that I could snap my fingers and resolve the turmoil that surrounds them, but I know deep down that I cannot.  Nonetheless the community is like a kaleidoscope, a collection of differences that when pieced together and accepted creates a beautiful image.

Standard

Everybody Matters: The Core of Cosmopolitanism

“Homo sum: humani nil a me alienum” (pg 111). With this statement, the “golden rule of cosmopolitanism” as Appiah refers it to, he is illustrating Terrance’s ideal of contamination, in which there is no society in the world that hasn’t been influenced (whether it’s culturally, religiously, politically, or even artistically such as in music and literature) by another society. We have all become intermingled together, so much so that there is no “cultural purity” (pg 113). It’s because of this inter-connectedness with one another across the globe that we can relate to and understand each other at a basic, human level. Appiah states that “cultures are made of continuities and changes” (pg 107) and sometimes these changes can be good and necessary (such as the growing acceptance of homosexuals in society) or unwelcoming because there is a shared feeling of a “threatened identity” (pg 103) within the society. This reminded me of the reading a few weeks ago, Outcasts United, because the native townspeople of Charleston felt threatened by the influx of refugees that were coming in and disrupting their homogeneity. To this, Appiah states that a threat to homogeneity is the cost of globalization. This is why cultures are ever changing, but still retaining their traditions and cultural identity.

Being a Mexican-American, I can definitely see the blending of these two cultures. From my Mexican culture, there is a growing movement of Spanglish within the younger generation. It’s not so much as integrating both Spanish and English, but also the emergence of new Spanish words (that aren’t “real” words in the sense that they have no real meaning) that are derived from English words. From the American culture, there are taquieras and Mexican supermarkets, and of course Cinco de Mayo (even though it’s not celebrated in Mexico). The point is, there is contamination in almost every culture of the world. At the same time, Appiah is warning us not to get carried away by only respecting each other’s differences and forgetting about also respecting each other for sharing a common human thread.

Appiah moves on to say that because of this shared common thread, we should have moral universals. The problem, he states, arises when we ask ourselves “how to distinguish benign and malign forms of universalism” (pg 143). I think that there are “good” morals which we should all live by, and others that are “bad” because they violate basic human rights (such as FGM and stoning someone to death for committing adultery). Appiah states that “people have a right to their own lives” (pg 146) so if a girl decides she doesn’t want to go through the FGM procedure, she should be in control of her body. He goes on to say that “everybody matters” (pg 144) and to be a cosmopolitan, we need to be able to tolerate everyone’s beliefs, except those in which human lives can be potentially harmed because those aren’t “values worth living by” (pg 144). Counter-cosmopolitans, on the other hand, aren’t so tolerable and accepting of others’ beliefs.

Appiah dedicates his last chapter to our obligations to strangers. He states that we “would sacrifice hundred millions in order to save our little finger” (pg 157) because we place ourselves above everyone else. We forget that we share the world with others, and because of this we have a “collective obligation” (pg 163) to one another- even those individuals we will never meet. Appiah articulates the basic human rights (healthcare, food, shelter, education, etc.) that every person should be entitled to; and that it’s our collective obligation to meet these needs for everyone, but the question that is posed is: “how are these needs to be met?” (pg 163). Appiah states that if a nation is unable to provide these basic human rights to their citizens, then it’s part of our collective responsibility to “provide resources” (pg 164). This reminded me of my Service Learning experience at CYO Kid’s Club because I truly believe that I’m making a change in the lives of the children I work with. The Kid’s Club is an afterschool homework help program that is a great resource provider for children who aren’t getting help with their homework at home. After reading this chapter, it made me realize that Service Learning wasn’t just mandatory for this class, but also obligatory for me as a human being.

Standard

Individual Action and Collective Responsibility

In Suk Cha writes her opinion on human interaction on a global scale. “One of the reasons why modern humanity cannot claim vestiges of primordial fear of difference as viable cause for violence and conflict is that we humans share too much in common with each other in our societies. It is difficult to find any group or society that has not entered into some sort of cultural exchange with another.” (5) Her point made about this oneness of people brings rise to the questions of universals and potential implementation of those universals.

 

This debate is what Appiah spends majority of his time weighing in the final chapter of Cosmopolitanism. “These villages are connected with more places than they were a couple of centuries ago. Their homogeneity, though, is still the local kind” (102). This poses the fact that there is a line for universals- maybe that they should be there but to what extent? There should be some cultural contamination as Appiah calls, where there are universal rules that are broad and open for cultural interpretation. “The point is that people in each place make their own uses even of the most famous cultural commodities” (113).

 

In Chapter 8: “Who’s Culture Is It Anyway?” The discussion of where that line is and how we can efficiently create such a line when it comes to universals. As discussed earlier in the book as well, people should go to other cultures and look at them as a laboratory, an experiment, and pick and choose things that may work or benefit their own cultures. This is the good part of universals: people can take the things that work for their own specific culture and then apply them. This is where counter-cosmopolitanism takes place.

 

Early on Appiah makes clear that his definition of good and productive cosmopolitanism is more of a “partial cosmopolitanism” (xvii). To me there are two parts: the individual and the collective community. These two parts should be harmonious, whereas in counter-cosmopolitanism the individual piece is missing. These global thinkers are “believers without boarders” (137) which can be dangerous when applying universals. There is no room for that individual culture to implement a variation of the universal rule to fit their culture- there are just rigid rules from all cultures to follow. This is the benign verses malign universal argument.

 

The real point of Cosmopolitanism and the discussions we have been having all semester, really face the reality that I stated above: we are individual people living together in a collective community. It is out job to find this balance of taking care of ourselves and our actions and taking responsibility on a global level for actions we must take. This can be seen in all of our service learning. For me it is about using my privileged resources to make the best of myself and learn about the world to live in it responsibly. For working at MCCS this means holding myself in an appropriate manor and being a role model- being the change I wish to see in the world, in these kids. My more collective responsibility comes from finding root causes and trying to promote change or support universals that implement this change. At MCCS that means I sit down and discuss with teachers and experts on why these kids are here, how we can get them out, and most importantly how others won’t get in. Doing the right thing myself and fighting the right fights for others is that balance that cosmopolitanism asks for.

 

The golden rule of cosmopolitanism: “I am human; nothing human is alien to me” (111).

Standard

Shades

Appiah supports cultural contamination because of how it allows us to be exposed to one another’s varying cultures (107). It allows us to choose what practices/values to adhere to and follow and develop respect for each other’s differences. He says, “We do not need, have never needed, settled community, a homogeneous system of values, in order to have a home” (113). He goes to say that people can have differing values and still live amiably amongst each other. Often keeping something the same can hinder progress of a community because the risk of change isn’t being taken to see how relations among members in society can be approved. Care should then be encourage cultural contamination, because being exposed to different cultures gradually develops respect for one another’s differences and integration of various practices, values, and lifestyles.

Additionally he makes the notable difference between that of cosmopolitanism and universalism. He notes that universalism occurs through the belief that there is only one way to live but cosmopolitanism says no, there is not only one way;  there are many.  Cosmopolitanism promotes pluralism: there are many values we live although we cannot live by all of them; thus people from different societies embody different values. Cosmopolitanism also follows that of Fallibilism: our knowledge is imperfect and subject to revision upon to new evidence (144). Universalism is counter-cosmopolitanism. Appiah makes a powerful point that brought this concept home by referring to Osama Bin Laden’s invitation to join Islam and become brother and sister through the religion. Appiah comments, “Join us, the counter-cosmopolitans say…but each of them plans to trample on our differences…if we will not join them” (145). From the perspective of Cosmopolitans, if they do not want to do what others are doing, their actions are taken into account and respected because they view the world differently; cosmopolitans learn from those they disagree with. However, in Universalism, it’s either a do or die choice. It is the action of ignoring the interest of others that leads to universalism. As cosmopolitans, it is vital to recognize that the world is not black and white but rather composed of different shades of gray; and somewhere in that gray, we have an inescapable obligation to strangers whether we choose to recognize that or not (151).

Life is hard because there’s no rules or guidelines that tell us exactly what to do in the situations. In times of moral dilemmas, it is always important to not only look at the problem itself, but look at why it has occurred. In the last chapter, Appiah tells us to address the root causes of any issue—more importantly, social issues. Yes, saving a life is important but that is not the only thing that matters. “What matters is decent lives” (167). In referring to sending African children money across the globe, he asks, “If what you save them for is just another month or another year or another decade of horrible suffering, have you really made the best use of your money?” It is more important, more helpful and useful to address what has caused the problem to occur so that in the future, more lives can be saved—that people’s suffering does not occur in vain and is not prolonged. Our obligation as individuals in a collective society is to promote adequate conditions of life and meet our obligation to each other by ensuring basic entitlements (safety, food, housing, and clothing, comfort and care) are met (173). We need to make sure that everyone’s quality of life is at the very least adequate to provide for a successful life.

Through my experience at MCCS, people come from a large variety of backgrounds and cultures that have influenced the students. Their inappropriate and disrespectful behavior, at first, comes off as an issue with the individual but throughout the semester has proven to be caused by a deeper underlying problem. It is my belief that their experience with an inadequate amount of resources and support in their life has led to where they are in life today. It may help to discipline them and tell them repeatedly that they are not supposed to swear in class or drink alcohol but doing so does not address why they act the way they do.  It is then the responsibility of the moral individual to look past the front and not only recognize one’s obligation to those who do not have the adequate conditions to live a successful life and engage themselves in addressing the underlying issue at hand.

Standard

I am human

Appiah states that, except for a few remote villages, homogeneity is impossible to achieve due to globalization. The world and relationships are in a continuous state of change much to the horror of some (and to the excitement of others). Cultural preservationists believe that cultural authenticity must be maintained at all costs. However, such beliefs are unrealistic and unappealing. Appiah says, “Trying to find some primordially authentic culture can be like peeling an onion.” Some traditions are born from innovation, such as the invention of easier modes of transportation. Appiah asks the audience if we should reject all these “newer” traditions because they are not primordial. The truth is that the entire world has been interconnected for hundreds of centuries. Cultures affect one another in thousands of subtle and extreme ways.  “Cultural purity is an oxymoron. The odds are then, culturally speaking, you already live a cosmopolitan life enriched by literature, art, and film that come from many places, and that contains influences of many more.” Cosmopolitans believe that variety matters because it enriches the spiritual and physical life of an individual and that individual’s relationships with others. According to John Mill Stuart, author of On Liberty, “Different persons require different conditions for their spiritual development; and can no more exist healthily in the same moral, than all the variety of plants can exist in the same physical atmosphere and climate.” Variety gives people the option to live a life of many choices.

In his ninth chapter Appiah draws parallels between the Muslim and Christian faiths, and also points out many terrorists attacks made in the name of religion. “Universalism without toleration, it’s clear, turns easily into murder.” Religious intolerance, unfortunately, is not in our past. We can still attach the term “violent neofundamentalist” to, not only foreigners, but people within our own nation. “This is a view that can, perhaps, be held with a compassion that will lead you to want to convert those who eternal fates hang so precariously in the balance; but it is not one that necessarily leads to respect for those who are living in error.” One example I found to be surprising was that of Eric Rudolph. Rudolph committed several terrible acts such as killing an off duty officer at an abortion clinic in Birmingham. What I found shocking was that a few people openly admitted to identifying with Rudolph. A number of T-shirts and bumper stickers were printed with the slogan “Run Rudolph, run!” A young mother in Murphy said, “Rudolph’s a Christian and I’m a Christian and he dedicated his life to fighting abortion. Those are our values. These are our words. I don’t see what he did as a terrorist act.” Appiah believes that toleration requires a concept of what is intolerable. He believes that we as humans have obligations to one another, yet it sharply limits our scope of tolerance. Cosmopolitans commit themselves to finding universal truths. They believe in pluramism—there are many values worth living by but it is impossible to live all of them. It is the Cosmopolitan’s hope and expectations that different people will embody different values. The second aspect of cosmopolitanism is fallibilism—the sense that our knowledge is imperfect and is always up for improvement in the face of new evidence. Cosmopolitans believe in learning from those that they may disagree with. “We think people have a right to their own lives.” Appiah concludes his chapter by saying that we have a moral obligation to help strangers. That is our duty as human beings.

The misinformed about Cosmopolitanism would believe something similar to the writings of Robert Sibley:  “Cosmopolitanism as an ethical commitment strains to extend our concrete realities to include some distant and generalized ‘others’ who, we are told, are our global neighbors. The idea might give you the warm-and-fuzzies, but it’s nothing for which you’d be willing to go to war.” Appiah acknowledges that it is impossible to know billions of individuals, but it is essential to remember that obligations to strangers is not to demand that we have the same connection to those we are close to. Appiah delves deeply into what we do owe our strangers. The emergency principle implies that figuring out moral principles is difficult. One reason why life is difficult is because there are no easily identifiable principles. It is often unclear what the effects will be of what we do. Appiah says that our strangers have a right to basic needs—health care, food, shelter, education, etc.—so that they may lead decent lives.  They should have the options so that they may live out wholesome lives. For those who lack the resources to give themselves these basic needs, it can be considered our human obligation to provide them with the resources. However, Appiah stresses that we should not all carry the burden of caring for strangers alone. If each of us were to do our fair share, and nothing more, the world would be a much better place (though it can be complicated to identify what our fair share is). We should not contribute all our resources and efforts to help strangers that our own welfare, and the welfare of love ones, diminishes. Lastly, Appiah states that we cannot allow diversity to be an obstacle to helping strangers.

In “Transcultural Ethics” In-Suk Cha counters Appiah by asking the audience if we are geared to stir up conflict, can peace ever exist as an alternative to violence. Can we still achieve the human mission to help our strangers? Suk Cha believes that if we are biologically geared for war and conflict than we must also be programmed to desire peace and security. Despite our failure to achieve world peace, we continue to believe that true peace still exists. We see bits of peace here and there. Also, teachings such as Confucianism “prove the universality of the concept of peace need not be debated, but the history of human learning has taught us that there seems to be no universally valid directives and no absolute ethical autonomy whatsoever for the problems which coexistence poses.” Suk Cha supports Appiah’s statements that disagreement is the fundamental reason for conflict. The conflicts between people are bound by distinct times, places, communities/cultures. In this piece Suk Cha says: “One of the reasons why modern humanity cannot claim vestiges of primordial fear of difference as viable cause for violence and conflict is that we humans share too much in common with each other in our societies. It is difficult to find any group or society that has not entered into some sort of cultural exchange with another.” As Appiah illustrated earlier, are cultures have been woven together in some manner through globalization. Some traditions are brought about by innovation in different cultures. It is unrealistic to hope to maintain “pure” culture in different locations. That would mean a lack of innovation in smaller areas with fewer resources and an absence of engagement. If we were to concentrate solely on pure culture than we would neglect our strangers. According to Appiah, we can reach the type of ethics that Suk Cha wishes for if everyone were to work towards the common good of mankind.

Cosmopolitanism is not just about intelligence and curiosity, but it also deals with engagement. Appiah asks his audience to critically think about our everyday actions and whether or not those actions will negatively affect a stranger. He is not asking us to despair because of the endless amounts of problems that exist in our world, but he simply wants us to ponder. To be actively aware about these hard issues draws you into the cosmopolitan challenge—to keep in mind the strangers. I found the final chapters of Appiah to be both beautiful and challenging. If service-learning has taught me anything is that there are those who are ignored by their fellow man. Some students in Kids Club lack basic needs such as a proper home, a decent income, health care, and education intervention. I’ve come to realize that there are poor neighborhoods in all communities but there is an invisible wall built between the poor and the privileged. Sometimes we may dehumanize the marginalized community so that we don’t feel guilty that their basic needs are not met. I liked how Appiah said that we need to be aware of these issues, but we do not need to bear the burdens of the world. We simply need to do our fair share to help our strangers. I hope that by tutoring at Kids Club that I am doing my fair share by helping these students catch up in school.

Standard

Final Reflection Prompt! Cosmopolitanism 7,9,10 and “Toward Transcultural Ethics”

(You can skip chapter 8 in Cosmopolitanism–please focus on chapters 7 & 9 as these are the most crucial. Please use quotes from those chapters in relation to the points made in the pdf reading cited below.  Appiah also published an article in the NYTimes Magazine in 2006 that is based on these chapters: “Case for Contamination. (It was the cover story)

In “Toward Transcultural Ethics in a Multicultural World,” In Suk Cha writes,

One of the reasons why modern humanity cannot claim vestiges of primordial fear of difference as viable cause for violence and conflict is that we humans share too much in common with each other in our societies. It is difficult to find any group or society that has not entered into some sort of cultural exchange with another. (5)

And:

Can there be an ethics for peace that cuts across cultures? I stand with those who contend that we are already moving toward such an ethics and it is not an invisible hand that moves us, it is individual and collective agency. We have obligations though, as we never need have if we choose to believe that we are not responsible for decisions we make and the actions we take. Our obligations include examining the nature of societies in terms of their differences and similarities and in terms of how they change upon interaction. (6)

That human nature is conflicted and oppositional, there can be no doubt. That is surely one thing that every society has discovered, just as every society discovers that whatever is decent, beautiful and just exists only because of societal living. Civil union can bring out the best and likely the worst in human beings, but without civil union, there is no humanity. (10)

How does Appiah, support and illustrate these points in these last chapters? Why does Appiah support what he calls cultural “contamination” and what does he mean by the conceptual challenge inherent in his discussion of “counter-cosmopolitans,” of “how to distinguish benign and malign forms of universalism?” (143). Can you relate these points to or illuminate them through your service-learning experience?

Standard