“…it is not an invisible hand that moves us, it is individual and collective agency” (5).
We can all agree that in more ways than not we are all different. We go about living life with different values, morals, outlooks, and opinions; although they may be internalized. Yet we live within our communities and societies often trying to conform to a level of normalcy that has been laid out by those “above” and before us. It is almost a false sense of security, as we hunker down in our blanket of norm and tradition. Life is continually changing and as Darwin once said, it is the survival of the fittest. This is not determined necessarily by strength, but by the ability and willingness to adapt to the ever changing environment around you. It must be understood that although our differences create a uniqueness between us, it can can still easily divide us. “We need to remember it however if we are to understand why, how and what sort of differences come to divide us in destructive ways” (4). In Cosmopolitanism, John Stuart Mill was quoted,
If it were only that people have diversities of taste, that is reason enough for not attempting to shape them all after one model. But different persons also require different conditions for their spiritual development; and can no more exist healthily in the same moral, than all the variety of plants can exist in the same physical, atmosphere and climate. The same things which are helps to one person towards the cultivation of his higher nature, are hindrances to another… (104)
In correlation with this quote, Appiah provides his own interpretation on the matter, “If we want to preserve a wide range of human conditions because it allows free people the best chance to make their won lives, there is not place for the enforcement of diversity by trapping people within a kind of difference they long to escape” (105).
Bringing in Toward a Transcultural Ethics in a Multicultural World alongside Cosmopolitanism we will begin to examine the ideas of globalization, mundialization and the like. Globalization has been defined as, “…the process or vehicle by which ideas, habits, worldviews travel from one culture to another and are transformed in the process” (6). Mundialization,”…refers to historical human society and the earth inhabited by humankind” (6). The two connect together on different focal points and thus we are able to see that,
mundialization…the taking in of the outside world into our own lifeworlds, occurs through globalization, a process by which the ideas and customs of other cultures are transported into our homeworlds. In this process, what was once strange and unfamiliar is transformed into something comfortable and familiar. This is the process that is generally known as cultural assimilation and, by virtue of which the boundaries of our individual homeworlds become constantly widened. This phenomenon is called the ‘mundialization of home.’ What effects the mundialization of home is the mediation of common elements found in both the schemata of orientation of the homeworld and in that of the strange or alien world. (6)
Due to to the continual process of mundialization, our schemata utilized in our interpretations of the world constantly evolve and transform as time goes on. Thus, allowing us a more in depth, wise and wide comprehension of our reality.
In chapter 9 Appiah discusses the counter-cosmopolitans and the cosmopolitans. In terms of cosmopolitans, there is the understanding that, “Toleration requires a concept of the intolerable…cosmopolitans believe in universal truth…it is the realism about how hard the truth is to find [that guides them]….One truth [held on to], is that every human being has obligations to every other. Everybody matters: that is [the] central idea. And it sharply limits the scope of [their] tolerance” (144). Two main aspects of cosmopolitanism are the commitment to pluralism and fallibilism. Counter-cosmopolitans on the other hand, do in fact believe that there exists one right way for all of humanity to live by and that all of the differences between every human being is not a display of uniqueness, but a minor details in the background. “For the counter-cosmopolitans, then, universalism issues in uniformity…..Our understanding of toleration means interacting on terms of respect with those who see the world differently…..cosmopolitans think [they] might learn something even from those [they] disagree with. [They] think people have a right to their own lives” (146). Appiah describes at the end of chapter 9 how, “[t]he real challenge to cosmopolitans isn’t the belief that other people don’t matter at all; it’s the belief that they don’t matter very much” (153).
In reading chapter 10 I came across several supposed principles to live by:
If you can prevent something bad from happening at the cost of something less bad, you ought to do it.
If you are the person in the best position to prevent something really awful, and it won’t cost you much to do so, do it.
On the other hand a significant reason, “…that life is full of hard decisions is precisely that it’s not easy to identify single principles” (162).
In all finality, “Cosmopolitanism is about intelligence and curiosity as well as engagement” (168).
In correlation with my service-learning experience, I think back to the when Appiah stated that, “…our obligation is not to carry the whole burden alone. Each of us should do our fair share; but we cannot be required to do more” (164). I think of all the children I work with and the similarity of all their situations and the disparity that surrounds them, and the utter lack of resources. Kids Club, the community, and even myself can only do so much to help them and their families. Believe me at times I wish that I could snap my fingers and resolve the turmoil that surrounds them, but I know deep down that I cannot. Nonetheless the community is like a kaleidoscope, a collection of differences that when pieced together and accepted creates a beautiful image.